Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ
Near the lakeA downtown Loudon restaurant with large portions, New York-style pizza, and a menu that also covers BBQ, sandwiches, and Italian.
Goodfellas is in downtown Loudon, a short walk from the Tennessee River, and it occupies a specific niche in the area's dining: the place that does New York pizza, BBQ brisket, a Reuben, manicotti, and a Cuban sandwich all at the same address. This is the kind of menu that can go wrong, and a few reviewers have said so, but the majority of accounts describe all of it as competently done and the pizza specifically as the standout.
The pizza comes in at 18 inches and holds up under full toppings without the crust collapsing. Cheese coverage is even across the full pie. The Meatzza has its followers. The manicotti earns praise from people who are particular about it, on both portion and flavor. The brisket is better in the sandwich format than as a standalone plate. The ribs are worth ordering on their own. Reubens and Cubans both hold up. There is a back patio for outdoor seating.
The staff works the room with warmth and the dining room is clean. The owners are present. The place has become a regular stop for Loudon-area residents.
The menu is broad, running from Italian to BBQ to New York deli, and the pizza and brisket items are the kitchen's strongest territory. Verify your order before leaving if you are ordering takeout.
Tips
- The 18-inch pizza is a strong value for two people or more.
- The back patio is available in good weather.
- The Reuben and Cuban sandwiches have specific fans; they are reliable lunch options.
- The brisket is better in the sandwich format than as a standalone plate based on available accounts.
What people love
- The pizza: large, even cheese coverage, crust integrity that holds up under toppings.
- The manicotti and Italian plates.
- The ribs, worth ordering specifically.
- Large portions across most of the menu.
- Staff and owners who work the dining room and treat the place as a family operation.
- The back patio as an outdoor option in a downtown setting.
What to know
- The menu is broad; the pizza and Italian items are the kitchen's strongest territory.
- Verify your order before leaving if you are ordering takeout.
- Closed Mondays.
- The restaurant is in downtown Loudon, near the waterfront, which makes it useful for lake visitors.
Best time
Weekday lunch for the most relaxed service. Friday and Saturday evenings for the social atmosphere.
First visit
On Grove Street in downtown Loudon, close to the river. Walk in; the dining room has counter and table seating. The back patio is accessible from inside.
How to get in
Walk-in. No reservations noted. Takeout available.
With kids
The dining room and menu are family-friendly. Portions are large enough to share.
Signature items
- New York-Style Pizza (18 inch)
- Manicotti
- Brisket Sandwich
- Ribs
- Reuben
Location
Frequently asked
When is Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ open?
Open Tuesday through Sunday. Closed Mondays. Hours run 11 AM to 9 PM most days; 6 PM Sunday close.
Is Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ good for families with kids?
The dining room and menu are family-friendly. Portions are large enough to share.
How do I get to Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ?
On Grove Street in downtown Loudon, close to the river. Walk in; the dining room has counter and table seating. The back patio is accessible from inside.
Does Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ take reservations?
Walk-in. No reservations noted. Takeout available.
What should I order at Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ?
The signature orders are New York-Style Pizza (18 inch), Manicotti, Brisket Sandwich.
What should I know before visiting Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill-BBQ?
The menu is broad; the pizza and Italian items are the kitchen's strongest territory.
Last updated: April 30, 2026