Jay's New York Pizza & Grill
Near the lakeA sprawling Loudon restaurant with New York-style pizza at its core, backed by BBQ, a hot bar, and a full menu that gives large groups something for everyone.
Jay's is drawing strong accounts for pizza, solid BBQ, and a hot bar that covers comfort food staples. The dining room is large, the menu is long, and there is a full bar.
The pizza is the flagship item. The pepperoni and mushroom is the best pizza in Loudon County. The crust is solid NY-style and the ranch sauce is a strong accompaniment. The Philly pizza in deep-dish format has its fans. Brisket is the BBQ item with the most consistent praise: the brisket plate with okra, the brisket in a sandwich, and the brisket as a topping on a loaded spud all hold up. The Philly cheesesteak sandwich is a reliable order. Calzones are large and typically generate a second meal. The fried and smoked bologna sandwich is unexpectedly good. The hot bar, which covers meatloaf, fried chicken, corn, green beans, and mashed potatoes, is useful for groups with varied preferences.
The bar produces solid cocktails and there is music in the dining room.
Service can slow when the room fills; build in time on weekend evenings. The brisket quantity can run light on the occasional off night; the plate and brisket-in-a-sandwich formats are the stronger bet.
Tips
- The pizza and brisket are the kitchen's strongest output; order around those.
- The calzone is large; plan to take half home.
- Online ordering is available and at least one account describes staff calling proactively to confirm the order.
- The hot bar is a useful option for groups with varied preferences.
- If you have a dog, ask about outdoor seating; one account mentions a server bringing water and food for a dog on the patio.
What people love
- New York-style pizza with consistent crust quality and a ranch sauce worth ordering.
- Brisket, particularly in the plate and sandwich formats.
- The calzones, which are large and reliably made.
- The hot bar for families and mixed-preference groups.
- A full bar with attentive cocktail service on good shifts.
- A dining room large enough to handle groups without splitting them.
What to know
- Service can slow when the room is full; weekday evenings run more smoothly.
- Brisket quantity can vary; the plate and sandwich formats are the stronger bets.
- Mulberry Street in Loudon is near the lake area, making this a reasonable dinner destination after time on the water.
Best time
Weekday lunch or early dinner for the calmest service. Weekend evenings for the social atmosphere and the full bar.
First visit
On Mulberry Street in Loudon. The dining room is visible from the street. Walk in; the host stand is near the entrance.
How to get in
Walk-in, no reservations noted. Online ordering and delivery to nearby locations (including campsite delivery, per at least one account).
With kids
The hot bar is the easiest option for families with varied preferences. The dining room is large and casual. The server mentioned above brought care for a guest's dog, suggesting the environment is relaxed enough for families with pets at outdoor seating.
Signature items
- New York-Style Pizza
- Brisket Plate
- Fried and Smoked Bologna Sandwich
- Philly Cheesesteak
- Calzone
Location
Frequently asked
When is Jay's New York Pizza & Grill open?
Open seven days a week. Friday and Saturday hours extend to 10 PM.
Is Jay's New York Pizza & Grill good for families with kids?
The hot bar is the easiest option for families with varied preferences. The dining room is large and casual. The server mentioned above brought care for a guest's dog, suggesting the environment is relaxed enough for families with pets at outdoor seating.
How do I get to Jay's New York Pizza & Grill?
On Mulberry Street in Loudon. The dining room is visible from the street. Walk in; the host stand is near the entrance.
Does Jay's New York Pizza & Grill take reservations?
Walk-in, no reservations noted. Online ordering and delivery to nearby locations (including campsite delivery, per at least one account).
What should I order at Jay's New York Pizza & Grill?
The signature orders are New York-Style Pizza, Brisket Plate, Fried and Smoked Bologna Sandwich.
What should I know before visiting Jay's New York Pizza & Grill?
Service can slow when the room is full; weekday evenings run more smoothly.
Last updated: April 30, 2026